| Date | Location | Result | |
| 04/13/09 | Cambridge, Mass. | Stevens 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-16,30-23,30-20) | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Rochester, NY | Phila. Biblical 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-19,30-19,30-11) | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Rochester, NY | Medaille 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-25,30-22,30-23) | Box score |
| Mar 21, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, D'Youville College 2 (26-30,29-31,30-28,31-29,15-12) | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, D'Youville College 1 (31-29,27-30,30-11,30-26) | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, City College of NY 0 (30-21,30-18,30-23) | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Medaille College 2 (25-30,23-30,30-25,30-27,15-13) | Box score |
| Mar 11, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Lees-McRae College 3, Eastern Mennonite 2 (23-30,30-19,30-28,28-30,15-10) | Box score |
| Mar 07, 2009 | Lake Sumter, Fla. | Warner University 3, Eastern Mennonite 2 (25-30,30-26,30-22,22-30,15-11) | Box score |
| Mar 05, 2009 | Lake Wales, Fla. | Warner University 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-23,30-18,30-27) | Box score |
| Feb 28, 2009 | Mount Olive, NC | Lees-McRae 3, Eastern Mennonite 1 (30-20,30-21,28-30,30-27) | Box score |
| Feb 27, 2009 | Mount Olive, NC | Eastern Mennonite 3, York College (NY) 0 (30-26,30-28,30-24) | Box score |
| Feb 27, 2009 | Mount Olive, NC | Mt. Olive College 3, Eastern Mennonite 1 (30-19,30-23,27-30,30-16) | Box score |
| Feb 25, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Lancaster Bible 0 (30-24,30-17,30-27) | Box score |
| Feb 21, 2009 | Bristol, Tenn. | Lees-McRae 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-25,30-27,30-22) | Box score |
| Feb 21, 2009 | Bristol, Tenn. | Grand Canyon 3, Eastern Mennonite 2 (30-21,24-30,28-30,30-17,18-16) | Box score |
| Feb 20, 2009 | Bristol, Tenn. | King College 3, Eastern Mennonite 2 (30-28,26-30,30-28,26-30,15-13) | Box score |
| Feb 16, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Stevenson 1 (30-20,30-25,33-35,30-22) | Box score |
| 02/14/09 | Nazareth College | Vassar 3, Eastern Mennonite 1 (30-25,30-22,30-32,30-22) | Box score |
| 02/14/09 | Nazareth College | Nazareth 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-25,30-20,30-21) | Box score |
| 02/13/09 | Rochester, N.Y. | Stevens 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (30-28,30-19,30-22) | Box score |
| 02/13/09 | Nazareth College | Eastern Mennonite 3, Medaille 1 (30-23,27-30,30-20,30-27) | Box score |
| Feb 10, 2009 | Lancaster, PA | Eastern Mennonite 3, Lancaster Bible 0 (30-14,30-22,30-18) | Box score |
| Feb 07, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Phila. Biblical 3, Eastern Mennonite 1 (30-26,30-28,24-30,30-24) | Box score |
| Feb 05, 2009 | Mount Olive, N.C. | Mt. Olive College 3, Eastern Mennonite 1 (30-21,30-25,26-30,30-28) | Box score |
| Feb 03, 2009 | Stevenson, Md. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Stevenson 0 (30-23,30-22,30-25) | Box score |
| Jan 31, 2009 | Langhorne, Pa. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Philadelphia Bib. 1 (30-27,30-22,24-30,30-25) | Box score |
| Jan 28, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | King College 3, Eastern Mennonite 2 (23-30,29-31,32-30,30-28,15-11) | Box score |
| Jan 23, 2009 | Harrisonburg, Va. | Eastern Mennonite 3, Mt. Olive College 2 (30-26,19-30,21-30,30-22,15-10) | Box score |
| Jan 17, 2009 | New Paltz, NY | Sacred Heart 3, Eastern Mennonite 0 (33-31,30-27,34-32) | Box score |
| Jan 16, 2009 | New Paltz, NY | Eastern Mennonite 3, Emmanuel College 2 (30-32,28-30,30-23,30-18,15-9) | Box score |
| Jan 16, 2009 | New Paltz, NY | Eastern Mennonite 3, Elms College 0 (30-21,30-26,30-28) | Box score |